tr

Should I Sell My House Myself or Use a Real Estate Agent?

June 22, 2026

Every year, thousands of Australian homeowners ask the same question before listing their property: do I really need a real estate agent, or can I handle this myself? It is one of the most important financial decisions you will make, and the answer depends on your situation, your confidence, and how much you understand the process.

There is now a third option most sellers do not know about: a fixed-fee Collings Property Advisor who gives you professional guidance, negotiation support, and campaign strategy for a flat $4,500 + GST — without the 2-3% commission a traditional agent charges.

What Are Your Options When Selling?

Australian sellers have three real choices:

Option Cost Support Level Best For
Traditional Real Estate Agent 2-3% of sale price ($15,000-$30,000 on a $1M home) Full service representation Sellers who want everything handled
Private Sale / DIY $500-$2,000 (listing fees only) None — you are on your own Experienced sellers with motivated buyers already lined up
Collings Property Advisory $4,500 + GST (fixed fee) Expert advice, strategy, negotiation support Sellers who want professional guidance without full commission

The Problem With Going It Alone

Selling privately sounds simple until you are in the middle of it. The most common mistakes DIY sellers make:

  • Pricing too high or too low. Without comparable sales analysis, most sellers either leave money on the table or price themselves out of the market.
  • Accepting the first offer. Experienced agents and advisors know how to create competition between buyers and extract the highest possible price.
  • Weak contracts. A poorly structured contract can cost you far more than any agent commission.
  • No marketing strategy. Listing on a portal is not a campaign. Timing, presentation, copywriting, and channel mix all affect your result.
  • Emotional negotiation. Sellers who negotiate directly with buyers often make concessions they would never make with a professional in their corner.

The Problem With Traditional Agents

Traditional agents earn more when your house sells for more — but their incentives are not always aligned with yours. Common issues:

  • Commission structures reward a quick sale, not necessarily the best sale.
  • Agents often manage 20-40 listings simultaneously — your property is not always their priority.
  • On a $900,000 property, a 2.5% commission is $22,500. That is a significant cost for what is often a few weeks of work.
  • You have limited visibility into what is happening with your campaign, how buyers are responding, or what the agent is saying in private negotiations.

What a Collings Property Advisor Does Differently

A Collings Property Advisor is not an agent and is not a DIY kit. The service gives you:

  • Comparable sales analysis and pricing strategy
  • Campaign structure recommendations (private sale, auction, expressions of interest)
  • Marketing review and copywriting guidance
  • Buyer qualification support
  • Negotiation strategy and offer management
  • Contract guidance
  • Ongoing availability throughout your campaign

You stay in control. We give you the expertise, the strategy, and the confidence to make better decisions at every step.

Real Cost Comparison

On a $900,000 property:

  • Traditional agent at 2.5%: $22,500
  • Collings Property Advisory fixed fee: $4,500 + GST = $4,950
  • Saving: $17,550

Even if the advisory helps you achieve just $10,000 more on your sale price, the service pays for itself many times over.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still list on realestate.com.au and Domain if I use a property advisor?

Yes. A property advisor helps you with strategy, pricing, and negotiation — you can still list on any portal. We can also help you identify the right listing agent to use for marketing if you want portal access without full representation.

Is private sale legal in Victoria?

Yes. Private sales are legal across Australia. In Victoria, you need a Section 32 (Vendor’s Statement) prepared by a solicitor or conveyancer before selling, regardless of whether you use an agent.

What if I already have a buyer lined up?

This is one of the strongest use cases for property advisory. If you already have a buyer, you do not need a full agent campaign. A Collings Property Advisor helps you price accurately, structure the deal correctly, and negotiate confidently — at a fraction of the cost.

Do you act as my agent in negotiations?

No. A Collings Property Advisor provides advice, strategy, and negotiation coaching. You remain the decision-maker. This keeps the service at a fixed fee rather than a licensed representation arrangement.

Why Collings?

Collings has been advising Melbourne property owners for over 30 years. We created the Property Advisory service because we kept seeing sellers pay enormous commissions for outcomes they could have achieved with better information and guidance — without full-service representation.

Our advisors combine decades of real estate experience with GeeVee property intelligence — live suburb data, comparable sales, rental yields, and market timing signals — so every recommendation is grounded in current market reality, not opinion.

Get Started — $4,500 + GST Fixed Fee

Talk to a Collings Property Advisor about your selling situation. No commission. No lock-in. Just expert guidance at a price that makes sense.

Book a free 15-minute discovery call to discuss your property and find out whether advisory is right for you.

Visit collings.com.au/portal to get started.

Find your next property with Collings

Track suburbs, get matched to on-market and off-market listings, and manage your whole property search in one place. Access the Collings property portal.

Scroll to Top