tr

Should You Accept the First Offer? Michael Tomadakis on Assessing Offers with Evidence (2026)

September 21, 2026

Deciding on first offer acceptance can shape your property sale’s success. Michael Tomadakis advises Melbourne sellers to carefully assess each initial offer. While some first offers are genuinely the best in competitive markets, others may signal potential for negotiation or stronger future offers. Understanding the context is crucial—evaluate genuine alternative buyers, timing in your campaign, and if the offer matches comparable sales in your area. Always weigh each offer against real evidence, buyer behavior, and timing, and consult with your agent before making a decision.

Why Consider First Offer Acceptance?

The first offer on your property often appears unexpectedly, sometimes within days of listing. Many buyers believe they should wait for higher offers, but this approach can lead to missed opportunities. A strong initial offer often reflects a buyer’s willingness to commit and indicates genuine interest in your property. An early offer can sometimes avoid the pitfalls of a prolonged selling campaign, which can reduce buyer interest.

Assessing Buyer Behavior and Market Timing

Understanding buyer behavior is essential in this decision. Serious buyers often present their best offers early to avoid a drawn-out bidding process. Conversely, speculative buyers may test the waters with lower bids, hoping for a counteroffer. Assessing whether you are dealing with the former or latter requires experience and a keen eye. Michael recommends examining the offer within the broader market context—Are similar properties selling fast? Is demand high? These questions can help determine if accepting the first offer is wise.

Consulting with Your Agent

Your agent is an invaluable resource in the decision-making process. They offer insights based on current market trends, providing a strategy tailored to your situation. An agent helps determine if the first offer aligns with your property’s market value and guides you in evaluating whether waiting might yield better results.

First offer acceptance is not just about the numbers offered—it’s about recognizing the value in an offer and understanding market dynamics. By working with experienced professionals, sellers can ensure they make informed decisions that lead to successful and satisfactory sales outcomes.

For more guidance, contact Michael Tomadakis at Collings. Our expert real estate team helps you navigate offers, ensuring you secure the best possible outcome for your property sale.

Related Posts

Further Reading

Scroll to Top